I’ve decided it’s time to shake things up. Instead of doing the rankings as usual, I’m going to transition to something more like Bracket seeding. It was a wild weekend in college basketball and it’s starting to get serious with the bracketology. I thought I would take a look at a couple of the high profile brackets and then come up with my own seeding, about the first 6 seeds. I’m looking at the brackets from Lunardi, Palm, NBC and Bracket Wag. It looks like a couple of these haven’t updated since the losses on Saturday, but it gives me a starting point.
Not all the brackets provided a true seed list, but I did my best to figure it out. By averaging them, the true seeding list (1-6) would be something like:
- San Diego St
- Florida St.
- Seton Hall
- Penn St
- West Virginia
- Michigan St
- Ohio St
Like I said, a couple of these brackets haven’t been updated since the Saturday games. Arizona, Ohio St, and Marquette, as well as BYU and Michigan, didn’t appear in the top six seeds of all the brackets. I did a guesstimate to come up with this average of the top 1-6 seeds. So, that’s going to be what I start with. I’ll provide my true seeding below and then continue to update until Selection Sunday.
- San Diego St
- Florida St
- Seton Hall
- West Virginia
- Penn St
- Ohio St
- Michigan St
As you may recall, my old band from my days in Northern Virginia are getting back together for one last gig. A wedding in June. I gave some more details here. Our last practice with the whole group was in November. Tomorrow, we’re going to have another go. I’m flying up in the morning. We’re practicing tomorrow night and then I’m flying back on Saturday. I scheduled this originally on a day when the MadDoc was scheduled to be on call the next day. The MadDoc is off call for a bit as she recuperates from surgery, but the show must go on. So I’m flying tomorrow anyway.
I think one of the guitarists from the band is out tomorrow. But we’re going to make our way through as many of the songs as we can manage. The good thing after the last practice is that we pared down the list and most of what’s left are songs that we have done a million and six times.
Just in case you’re curious, here’s the new list we’re aiming for, in the order we’re thinking of playing them:
- American Band – Grand Funk Railroad
- What You Need – INXS
- What I Like About You – The Romantics
- Heart of Rock and Roll – Huey Lewis and the News
- 99 Red Balloons – Goldfinger
- Rock This Town – Stray Cats
- China Grove – Doobie Brothers
- Bad Case of Loving You – Robert Palmer
- Can’t Take My Eyes off of You – Muse cover of Frankie Valli tune
- Rock and Roll All Night – Kiss
- Don’t Gotta Work It Out – Fitz and the Tantrums
- Jumpin Jack Flash – Rolling Stones
- Back in the USSR – Beatles
- Play That Funky Music – Wild Cherry
- I Want You To Want Me – Cheap Trick
- Lido Shuffle – Boz Scaggs
- If You’re Wondering If I Want You To – Weezer
- I’m a Believer – Monkees/Smashmouth/Neil Diamond
- Kiss Me – New Found Glory cover of Sixpence None the Richer tune
- Last Nite – The Strokes (but I don’t sing this one)
- Semi Charmed Life – Third Eye Blind
- That Thing You Do – The Wonders
- American Girl – Tom Petty
- Drive My Car – Beatles
- Accidentally In Love – Counting Crows
- Maybe I’m Amazed – Paul McCartney
- I Saw Her Standing There – Beatles
- Shut Up and Dance – Walk the Moon
- Hold On Loosely – .38 Special
- Synchronicity II – The Police
- Happy Together – The Turtles
- Long Train Running – Doobie Brothers
- Hard to Handle – Black Crowes
- My Love – Paul McCartney
- Closing Time – Semisonic (to wrap things up?)
- Freebird – Lynyrd Skynyrd (not necessarily played here, but you know someone will call out Freebird)
- Birthday – The Beatles (in case someone has a birthday)
There were only six people on the stage tonight. No Tom Steyer, no Andrew Yang and welcome Michael Bloomberg.
A very interesting and combative debate tonight. Plenty of attacks on Bloomberg. Sanders got some attacks, but not as many as the front-runner would normally expect. Pete and Amy don’t like each other and that showed.
The first hour or so was electric. All of the attacks on Bloomberg came out. They asked about the socialist thing with Bernie. Bloomberg called it communism. Amy asked if Pete was calling her dumb. It was really a fun debate from that perspective.
When I get to my ranking, I’m going to go into who I think did the best in the actual debate. But if you want to say whether the debate performances will have an effect on the vote in Nevada or South Carolina or beyond, that’s harder to say. Looking at this issue, I think Bernie came out ahead, even though his debate performance was just OK. He wasn’t attacked and, as the front runner, that means he’s a winner. Bloomberg was terrible in the debate, but how many people actually watched the debate? Are his ads going to save his overall standing in the race? Warren was probably the best in the debate (not just me saying it), but will it actually help her? Maybe not.
On to the ranking:
- Elizabeth Warren – Really good debate. She attacked effectively Bloomberg. A little less effective when she did her scattershot attacks on a bunch of candidates at a time. With the time limits, doing serial attacks like that probably were good tactics, since there was never going to be enough time for everyone to respond. She got a really good response from the crowd on her 2 cent wealth tax, which actually does poll really well.
- Joe Biden – Joe attacked judiciously but didn’t overdo it. Some of his answers were just straight out of his plans, but for Joe that may be a good thing. Joe may have benefitted from Bloomberg having a bad debate. He looks pretty progressive next to Republican-lite Bloomberg.
- Bernie Sanders – Part of the reason I put Bernie here is that he really wasn’t attacked. If you’re the front-runner and you don’t get attacked, you had a pretty good debate. There was some attempt to pin Bernie down on the cost of his healthcare plan. He avoided a straight answer as he usually does and just talked about healthcare as a human right and the US is the only developed country that hasn’t figured it out. He also skated on the transparency of his medical records and his online supporters. I did appreciate that he disavowed anyone attacking people online and said they’re not part of his movement. I suspect I may use that line in my own discussions with Bernie supporters online.
- Pete Buttigieg – I liked Pete’s line about how we should nominate a Democrat. We shouldn’t have to choose between someone who wants to burn the party down and another person who wants to buy the party out. Deduct points for the Pete-Amy squabbles.
- Amy Klobuchar – For me, Amy won the last debate. She was off her game tonight. Part probably because Warren had such a good debate and that took some of the space she could have had. Also, she lost in the squabble with Pete. She more clearly than Pete showed her dislike for him. He might also dislike her, but he hides it better.
- Mike Bloomberg – Just a terrible debate. He wasn’t prepared for questions that should have been obvious. If you’ve seen his ads and then saw this debate, you might not recognize the man tonight. One thing he did better than everyone else, was talk about beating Trump. I’m just not sure Bloomberg can beat him and I don’t think he represents the Democratic values we want our nominee to have. I’ll vote for him if he’s the nominee, but he’s likely down here at the bottom in my overall candidate ranking as well.
We’ve got early voting in Tennessee and it extends until next Tuesday, at least here in Knox County. I’ve been a Warren supporter since last summer, so it has been my plan to vote for her in the primary for a long time. Recently, though, the rise of Bernie has changed the calculation a bit. I was toying with the idea of holding off on voting until after the Nevada caucus to make sure that Warren isn’t completely out of the running by Super Tuesday. But I figured I should vote my heart here in the primary no matter what. So I turned the little circle thing and voted for Elizabeth and me on my ballot. The only races with Dems in them in my precinct.
No matter what happens in the Primary, I’m blue no matter who. We need to vote Trump out of office.
See you after tonight’s debate.
Will any of the top 3 (Gonzaga, Baylor, San Diego State) lose before the NCAA tournament? Or Duke, Kansas, Dayton? I think Kentucky is maxed out at a 2 seed and that’s only if they win out. Probably a 3 seed. Beat LSU on Tuesday and things look good for the 2.
- Gonzaga (26-1)
- Baylor (23-1)
- San Diego State (26-0)
- Duke (22-3)
- Kansas (22-3)
- Dayton (23-2)
- Maryland (21-4)
- Auburn (22-3)
- Kentucky (20-5)
- Penn State (20-5)
- Oregon (19-6)
- Florida State (21-4)
- Colorado (20-6)
- Villanova (19-6)
- Houston (20-6)
- Creighton (20-6)
- Louisville (21-5)
- Vermont (21-6)
- Seton Hall (18-7)
- West Virginia (18-7)
- LSU (18-7)
- Butler (19-7)
- Wichita State (17-5)
- Iowa (18-8)
- Rhode Island (19-6)
I’ve always thought this was a great song. One lyric came to me again today in the midst of the fall of Warren and the rise of Bernie:
“Tax the rich/feed the poor/Till there are no/rich no more?”
I’ve got no problem with taxing the rich or feeding the poor. I always thought the goal ought to be no poor no more. Maybe it doesn’t flow as well in the world of songwriting. But, I wonder if that’s the difference between Warren and Sanders supporters. Warren supporters focus on eliminating poverty, while Sanders supporters want to get rid of the rich?
Just a thought.
We’ve had the Iowa Caucus debacle and the New Hampshire primary, so I think it’s time to update my ranking. Andrew Yang and Michael Bennett dropped out (although Bennett hasn’t been in my ranking for a long time). Biden is on life support and Warren looks to be done. Bernie is the frontrunner, while Pete and Amy are vying to be the main moderate alternative. And Bloomberg is waiting in the wings. What to do, what to do?
- Elizabeth Warren – Staying steady. I think there’s a chance that Warren doesn’t make it to South Carolina. She’s probably running out of money and, if she doesn’t pull out a huge surprise in Nevada, I suspect she’ll drop out while she still has some support left. From the clips of her speech last night, I suspect if she endorses, she might be going for Klobuchar. She probably won’t endorse, but I’m guessing the Bernie supporters online have soured her and her campaign on an endorsement of Bernie (even though they’re closer in policy ideas). I could probably write a whole piece on the reasons why she has fallen. I suspect her supporters overlapped with Bernie (policy), Pete (college educated white voters) and Amy (women) and, since those 3 surged, the votes had to come from somewhere. I will keep Warren at number one on my ranking until she officially drops out, but I suspect it’s gonna happen sooner rather than later.
- Amy Klobuchar – Staying steady. I’ve said from very early on that, all things considered, I prefer a woman at the top of the ticket. I suspect Amy is still more of a VP prospect than someone who gets the top spot. Still, she’s in the middle of a surge and represents a good counter point to Bernie’s revolution. Nevada is going to tell the tale for the moderate lane. I think she’s in good shape now to make it to Super Tuesday. Then, let’s see. If she doesn’t get the nomination, it’s looking tough for her to get on the ticket. She and Pete don’t get along. Biden is toast. If Bloomberg somehow wins, she might be a good fit for his ticket. She’s not a fit for Bernie. And those seem to be the options at this point.
- Pete Buttigieg – up 1 spot. He shared the win in Iowa and came close in New Hampshire. He’s been competitive in Trump areas, so he has a good theory of the case for how he is going to appeal to independents. I like the youth and I think he can generate some enthusiasm. Pick the right VP and that’s a strong ticket.
- Bernie Sanders – up six spots. Bernie is the frontrunner. He can generate enthusiasm. There are polls that show him beating Trump. He’s got just terrible, horrible, no good, very bad supporters online. Not all of them, but there are some terrible folks out there. I like many of his ideas. The reason he’s down here is because of his supporters. And his age and the socialist label. I still say the Trumpies have laid off him because he’s their preferred opponent. They will go after the socialist thing and I’m afraid it’s going to stick. Still, with a good VP pick, he can rally the base. Maybe some of the terrible people online would vote for Trump or sit out if not for Bernie? So, not my first choice, but I’m gonna vote for him if he’s the nominee.
- Joe Biden – down two spots. He’s toast. Maybe he stays in til South Carolina, but he’s kind of in the same boat as Warren.
- Michael Bloomberg – staying steady. I’m not a fan of the billionaire buying the nomination thing. Once he’s on the debate stage and some of his Republican policies come to light, I don’t think he can win. Still, I’ll vote for him over Trump. And he’s on here in this spot, because there are no other viable candidates after him.
- Tom Steyer – staying steady. Another billionaire. Maybe better than Bloomberg, but not viable.
- Michelle Obama – staying steady. Just because.
- Stacey Abrams – staying steady. Because she’s a great option for VP.
- MadDog, Esq. I’m up for election locally. Besides the top 6 or so here, I’m as likely to write myself in and vote for anyone else.